The incident took place while the Scarsdale woman was walking her dogs in the village on Popham Road Thursday, Nov. 22.
The woman said she was approached by the two men who asked for money, police said.
When the woman turned toward the men, she saw a handgun and screamed, causing the men to flee the scene.
Descriptions of the suspects were not released.
Anyone with information should contact Scarsdale Police at 914-722-1200.
Click here to follow Daily Voice Rye and receive free news updates.